Armchair General small spacer
Armchair General magazine mastheadGo to Weider History GroupSubscribe to Armchair General MagazineLearn about latest issue of Armchair General

Smoking al Qaida and the Taliban Out of Pakistan’s Tribal Region

Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina of Bangladesh and Carl Ciovacco | January 05, 2009  | 8 comments  | Print  | E-mail

A jingle truck packed with people and farm animals crosses into Afghanistan at the Torkham Gate crossing. Thousands of people use this border crossing between Pakistan and Afghanistan each day. Photo by Petty Officer 1st Class Scott Cohen.
A jingle truck packed with people and farm animals crosses into Afghanistan at the Torkham Gate crossing. Thousands of people use this border crossing between Pakistan and Afghanistan each day. Photo by Petty Officer 1st Class Scott Cohen.

Subscribe Today

Increasingly, the focus on the War on Terrorism is turning to Pakistan’s troubled tribal region. Both the current Bush administration and the incoming Obama transition team have singled out the Pakistan-Afghanistan border region as a high priority. This insightful article by Sheikh Hasina, Bangladesh’s newly elected prime minister who previously served in that office from 1996 to 2001, and Carl Ciovacco provides policy makers struggling with this issue a template for successful action. – EDITOR, Armchair General magazine

Pakistan and Federally Administered Tribal Area. University of Texas Libraries.
Pakistan and Federally Administered Tribal Area. University of Texas Libraries.
As counterterrorism experts and statesmen around the world ponder the best strategy to defeat al Qaida and the Taliban, a nuanced approach at solving the ills of Pakistan’s Federally Administered Tribal Area (FATA) could provide the answer. By transforming the region from a lawless, drug supplying, smuggling epicenter bent on fighting the federal government and instigating international violence, to a rehabilitated province flourishing with schools, hospitals, and a legitimate agrarian source of income, al Qaida and the Taliban would find themselves without a home. This rehabilitation would usher in conditions inhospitable to drug and arms smugglers and terrorists. What bunker-busters and guns have failed to do to al Qaida and the Taliban hiding in the remote mountainous lattice, tribal area rehabilitation could accomplish. The success story of the Chittagong Hill Tract (CHT) tribal area of Bangladesh could serve as a template to heal Pakistan’s tribal region and effectively smoke the terrorists out of their safe-haven.

Bangladesh and Chittagong Hill Tract tribal areas. University of Texas Libraries.
Bangladesh and Chittagong Hill Tract tribal areas. University of Texas Libraries.
The similarities between the CHT tribal region in Bangladesh and the FATA in Pakistan are striking. Both tribal areas are remote, autonomy-seeking, mountainous enclaves on the borders of their respective countries, and marginalized by the ruling majority party. They are extremely poor and only account for a small portion of their country’s total land mass and population. Opium, weapons and drug smuggling, and armed conflict between the tribes and their government thrived in the CHT as it does today in the FATA. How then has the Chittagong become a law-abiding area that now produces corn for its country instead of opium while the FATA remains a thorn in the side of Pakistan, its neighbors, and the rest of the world? The answer to this question may supply a remedy to al Qaida and the Taliban’s increased control and influence over the region and its opium trade. If Pakistan can make the FATA look more like the Chittagong, al Qaida and the Taliban will lose not only their base of operations but also the drug money that is helping fund their global terrorist network.

Pages: 1 2 3

Tags: , ,

  1. 8 Comments to “Smoking al Qaida and the Taliban Out of Pakistan’s Tribal Region”

  2. Interesting article, and very good plan, yet the approach hide the fact that a foreing extremist organization is already operating in the FATA in strenght. A plan must to rehabilitate the FATa must also involve dealing with the armed organization that has every interest to derail it.

    By Arrigo Velicogna on Jan 5, 2009 at 3:44 pm

  3. Navy Admiral Mullen, Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, said in a speech on 9 February 2009 that, “It has gotten worse in Afghanistan, violence is up, [and] the Taliban is back.” With that said, the importance of trying a new strategy as explained in this article is critically important. Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina and Mr. Carl Ciovacco provide a sound strategy to solve some of the problems in Pakistan which are migrating to Afghanistan.

    Joe Neal, US Army, Lieutenant Colonel (Ret)

    By Joe Neal on Feb 10, 2009 at 4:36 pm

  4. With PM Sheikh Hasina’s election in December, her clout in the region has risen. What she has done in Bangladesh’s tribal region could be replicated in Pakistan. The PM and Carl Ciovacco’s framework could provide an answer to a difficult challenge in Pakistan and Afghanistan with al Qaeda and the Taliban. The truest challenge will be in its implementation.

    By Paul Darmory on Feb 10, 2009 at 5:03 pm

  5. I think this plan can work.

    By Rascal on Feb 10, 2009 at 5:09 pm

  6. Well considered. I would submit that alternative crops, along with accompanying training as you discuss, are a crucial part of the plan.

    By Tom Pallas on Feb 11, 2009 at 12:37 pm

  7. Hasina was sworn in as Prime Minister on 6th January 2009. How come this article refers her as PM before this official date of assuming power?

    By bdfact on Oct 1, 2009 at 4:37 am

  8. The article is interesting and pragmatic. Just few months back her son wrote another paper which seems to say the opposite. Read comparisons of both at realtimebangladesh.blogspot.com.

    By Mahmudul on Oct 3, 2009 at 4:39 pm

  9. The article is interesting and pragmatic. Just few months back her son wrote another paper which seems to say the opposite. You can read the <a heref="realtimebangladesh.blogspot.com" comparisons here . .

    By Mahmudul on Oct 3, 2009 at 4:43 pm

Post a Comment

Please note that Armchair General Staff cannot respond to requests for research of any type. Please visit our research forum to post research questions. If you have a question about our magazine, please use the contact us form.

Related Articles



Armchair General Spacer

SPONSORED SITES




Armchair General Spacer

OPINION POLL

Q: Of the three options presented in ACG's What Next in Afghanistan? article, which offers the greatest hope for success?

View Results

See previous polls

STAY CONNECTED WITH US

RSS Feed
 
Daily Armchair General Update
 
 

Armchair General on Twitter Armchair General on Myspace Armchair General on Facebook

What is Armchair General?

Armchair General (ACG) and ACG online feature a unique, interactive editorial approach that invites the reader to decide the course of action in challenging historical scenarios, to step into the shoes of a battlefield commander. Leading historians and contributors lend integrity and credibility to this fresh presentation of historical and contemporary events.

Armchair General is the INTERACTIVE history magazine where YOU COMMAND and decide the course of action!

Armchair General's Feedburner Link Get our RSS!
Weider History Group Newsletter Newsletter Signup

What We Write About

Our Other Magazines

Weider History Network:  HistoryNet | Armchair General | Great History | Achtung Panzer!

Copyright © 2004-2008 Armchair General L.L.C., All rights reserved.