Pages Menu
TwitterRssFacebookYouTube

Categories Menu

Posted on Aug 25, 2010 in Electronic Games

Over Flanders Fields – PC Game Review

By Rick Martin

Over Flanders Fields: Between Heaven and Hell. PC Game Review. OBD Software. Over Flander’s Fields $29.99; Hat in the Ring Expansion $19.99

Passed Inspection: Amazing graphics. Many types of one- and two-seat planes from all four years of World War I. Fascinating and challenging campaigns. As addictive as a game can be. May set the realism to match the skill of the player.

Failed Basic: Must have Microsoft Combat Flight Simulator 3 (MCFS3) to play and that game had a few crash issues. A few issues with confirmation of kills. Some other minor quibbles.

A nearly perfect re-creation of the Great War as seen by the pilots serving in their country’s air corps.

For years I’ve been trying to find a World War I flight simulator that takes advantage of the PC platform’s advancements over the years. Back in the 20th century (Wow—doesn’t that sound strange?) I used to play any World War I flying game I could get my hands on. From Blue Max on the Commodore 64 to Knights of the Sky and Red Baron on the Amiga, I loved and hated them all. When I found out about a Red Baron 3D expansion for the PC, I tried and tried to get the damn thing to work but finally gave up in frustration. The fact that a friend who is a programmer by trade couldn’t get the Red Baron 3D expansion to work finally sealed its fate in my mind. Just as I’d about to give up on a great World War I flying game for the PC, along came Over Flanders Fields: Between Heaven and Hell (OFF) by OBD Software.

Subscribe Today

First off, let me state that OFF is not a stand-alone game for your PC; it is an expansion to Microsoft Combat Flight Simulator 3 (MCFS3) so you are going to need that game to play OFF. Aside from having to own MCFS3 to play OFF, be aware that OFF is held hostage to many of the glitches inherent in MCFS3, but this is a small price to pay for the amazingly immersive biplane experience that OFF gives you. For their part, OBD Software has actually provided fixes for many of the bugs in MCFS3 and even improved the graphics. One of the many things they have added is visual damage—you can see the large chunk of wing flapping in the air as you try to land your flak-damaged biplane, as happened to me on one flight. It was an adventure just trying to avoid combat and get my newly un-aerodynamically sound plane back to a friendly airfield.

It is highly recommended that before you play OFF that you install the two patches which are available at OBD Software’s highly informative website. The patches fix some issues with the game, which include a highly frustrating (but perhaps realistic) need to have every single kill subject to a verification process. This process devalidated over 40% of all my kills before I installed the patch and turned on the “easy verification” process. The patches also add some airplanes and fix some minor glitches.

OFF fans may also purchase a new expansion for the game called “Hat in the Ring,” which adds even more airplanes and special features.

One of my big complaints with some World War I biplane games has been the low selection of playable airplanes. This is not an issue with OFF. A selection of the flyable one- and two-seaters include: Eindeckers; Spads; Sopwiths of all types including the Strutters, Pups, Triplanes and Camels; Albatrosses; RE8s; CIIs; Fokker Dr-1s; Fokker DVIIs; Pfalzs; Nieuports; DH2s —the list goes on and on. Each plane has its own flying characteristics so, for example, when you are used to an Albatross and then start flying a Sopwith Triplane, you have to struggle to keep the Sopwith from trying to gain height—it goes up like a rocket. I’ve found it to be the perfect plane to go after German two-seaters, but it can’t dive very well. Every player will want to try the famous Fokker DR-1 triplane, an amazing climber and almost as maneuverable as a hummingbird, but it can’t escape by speed alone if you’re being chased. One of my favorites of the early to mid-war German planes is the Halberstadt and my pilot, who started on an Eindecker, is now flying one and has racked up 14 kills.

As I stated previously, OBD has added visual damage to the planes. You know when you’ve been hit and can even see what’s been done to your plane. Fires are a danger in these canvas birds and the AI in OFF knows it. One time while attacking a German two-seater with my Sopwith Camel, the German plane lit on fire. The next thing I know I hear a scream from the pilot as he gives up and jumps over the side of the plane to escape the flames! This was a sobering moment as I realized just how detailed OFF was. I actually felt bad for the pilot and for the gunner who didn’t jump but held on for dear life as his plane plummeted from the sky and the flames spread towards him. OBD has informed me that due to some concern over issues of emotional distress, they have provided an option that can turn off the more psychologically troubling aspects of this realistic damage.

A dynamic campaign mode allows the player to fly for France, the USA, Britain or Germany. After picking your country, you then pick whether you are flying fighters or two-seaters. (OBD has not programmed in the large bombers such as the Gotha or Handley Page yet.) Then you pick your squadron and the date on which your pilot starts flying. The date advances as your character progresses. The available airplane types and the weather change based upon season and year. The weather can even change during the course of a mission. One of my pilots started flying in low clouds, high wind gusts and rain, but by the time he made it back to base (after downing three enemy planes, thank you very much), the sun was beginning to come out and the wind had died down. The campaign mode is fully immersive: it tracks your kills, health and other aspects, including the prospect of your squadron being transferred to another air base.

You may avoid the campaign mode if you wish and either create your own or choose from pre-designed missions or you can just jump in to a good, old-fashioned multi-player shoot ‘em up.

For ground attacks, OBD has provided a full army of units, from machine gunners and cavalry to World War I–era tanks and trucks. Attacking ground targets is fun but be prepared for the nasty effects of ground fire and flak. Also, watch out for hitting civilian refugees—the squadron commander is not overly fond of you massacring civilians, so know what you’re shooting at before you attack. Balloon busting is another fun but dangerous mission alternative.

Players also have the option of changing the paint job on their planes, but I have had difficulty figuring out what the new paint job looks like until the mission starts. A “view new paint scheme” option would be nice (hint, hint).

I have also had difficulty with the maps not being terribly accurate, but perhaps this is also the “realism factor” messing with my gaming sensibility.

Another minor fly in the ointment is that you can’t uninstall the patches without re-installing the entire game, which is a rather time-consuming experience. It would be very nice had OBD included an “uninstall patch” option.

OFF is very processor-intensive, so before you purchase it, go to OBD’s website to make sure your system can handle it.

A few quibbles not withstanding, I found Over Flanders Fields to be one of the best flying games I have ever experienced. It is a nearly perfect re-creation of the Great War as seen by the pilots serving in their country’s air corps. Highly recommended but be warned—it is also highly addictive!

Armchair General rating: 88% before patches; 91% after patches

About the author:
A college film instructor and founder of Nouveau Cinema Group, Inc., an organization which rescues old movie theaters, Richard Martin has also worked in the legal profession, is involved in video production, film criticism, sports shooting and is an avid World War 1 and 2 gamer who can remember war games which came in plastic bags and cost $2.99 (he’s really that old)!

Screenshots provided by Michael Burnside.

14 Comments

  1. Your review of “Over Flanders Fields” is very good; I am flying this sim for quite some time now without having explored all that is offered.
    The only bad spot are your pictures / screenshots. They look like being made without any Anti-Aliasing and with a low resolution. I can assure you, that the sim can look much, much greater than that, and I want to invite everyone to check out the “Screenshots” section in OFF’s forum:

    http://combatace.com/topic/37244-screen-shots

    Perhaps you can replace the pics with some from there?

  2. Nice that you gave BHaH the recognition it deserves. It’s one of the best flight sims of all time. Thank you.

    My only niggling complaint is that the graphics are much better than those portrayed in your review. There is a wealth of great screenshots and videos to be found on the combatace website and Youtube.

  3. Great article, horrible screenshots.. what system was your reviewer using? He must have been an older PC and video card with alizing. With a even half way decent system the graphics are fantastic in OFF and this article makes that look bad. Why not pick out some screenshots from the Combat Ace screen shots sticky forum and use those, I know that you will get 100% cooperation on this. Tfhank you!

  4. Ah, great – you replaced the screenshots! This sim is so good and immersive, that it deserves it. It “ate my heart”.

    I just need to add this info: the HUD instruments and the blue info text can be switched off, or moved around on the screen to find your individual positions. Info like “Labels”, “Messages” or “Simulation warnings” can be switched on or off. Flight model and many other things can be set up individually in a “Workshop”.

    If anyone likes to visit the “General discussion” of OFF Pilots:
    http://combatace.com/forum/204-off-general-discussion/

    Thank you for your quick respond!

  5. Your review for BHaH is wonderful… I stumbled across it on Combatace and after debating for a month or so took the plunge and I have not looked back since every time I take a flight it always gives me a sense of wonder and I have been flying it for a year now. Your write up is spot on…

    But there is one negative to the write up is the Screenshots as they are terrible even on my 4 year old PC I get a better graphic setup… and the graphics for BHaH are wonderful to view.

  6. Apologies for second post… my comment about the screenshots was from when I first viewed it a few days ago… and I didn’t realise that you had changed them so my apologies and thanks for listening to our request as someone once said a picture is a 1000 words…

  7. How does this compare to Rise of Flight, in terms of realism, campaign (RoF has no dynamic campaign as yet), gameplay? Anyone played both?

  8. BigArrow,

    I won’t open up a comparison discussion here but would refer you to the feature page of OFF’s website.

    http://www.overflandersfields.com/Features.htm

    where you may draw you own conclusion.

    I will only say that OFF’s dynamic campaign is its shining strength.

    I’ll add my appreciation of the review, too. Thanks Richard.

  9. Have to agree – it’s a thoroughly immersive game, to the point where I have simply deleted the other games of my rig and play this.

    It’s heartstopping and quite breathtaking, and I don’t suppose I’m the only player who heaves a massive sigh of relief when back on terra firma after a mission.

    Well recommended to WWI fans, and air sim fans.

  10. i cannot wait to fly this myself,,i’m in the hunt for a good pc. one question i have is that my monitor is a analog,,must i up date that as well??

  11. Thanks for this review Richard. I have been flying OFF since April 2011 and I have been pleasantly surprised by how good this SIM really is. The dynamic campaign is second-to-none and the support within the OFF community is something to behold.

    Some may get put-off by the fact that OFF is an expansion of Microsoft Combat Flight Simulator 3 (CFS3) but leave your reservations at the door. This is worlds-above CFS3.

    I have close to 20 games on my PC but over the last 6 months I have not touched any of them. OFF provides what I need in a flight-SIM experience and I highly recommend it to anyone.

  12. would like to install Off but my p.c. is not fast enough,,,so i will have to wait for awhile,,,,rats

  13. OFF is more CPU-depenpent than GPU so maybe just a simple upgrade will get you in the game RACPOPS?

    Also, visit the forums. There are a number of people who are running this on older computers. If you post to the General Discussion section http://combatace.com/forum/204-off-general-discussion/, someone should be able to answer your questions.

  14. Hello,I check your blogs named “Over Flanders Fields – PC Game Review | Armchair General | Armchair General Magazine – We Put YOU in Command!” like every week.Your humoristic style is awesome, keep up the good work! And you can look our website about proxy server list.

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Wings Over Flanders Fields – PC Game Review | Armchair General | Armchair General Magazine - We Put YOU in Command! - […] been nearly five years since I reviewed the original Over Flanders Fields and, with this new release of the …

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>