Pages Menu
TwitterRssFacebookYouTube

Categories Menu

Posted on Mar 2, 2015 in Armchair Reading

CDG 67 – Falklands War Battle, 1982

CDG 67 – Falklands War Battle, 1982

By Armchair General

The March 2015 issue of Armchair General® presented the Combat Decision Game “Falklands War Battle, 1982.” This CDG placed readers in the role of British Lieutenant Colonel Hew Pike, commander of 3d Battalion, the Parachute Regiment (3 Para), a light infantry unit which was part of 3 Commando Brigade. Pike’s mission on June 11, 1982 was to attack and defeat Argentine forces occupying Mount Longdon. The mountain was dominant terrain whose possession by the enemy blocked any further British advance to recapture Stanley, the Falklands’ principal town and administrative center. With British forces in the Falkland Islands operating at the end of a tenuous 8,000-mile long supply line while Royal Navy task force ships supporting the campaign were receiving devastating air attacks from Argentina-based enemy warplanes, bringing the war to a rapid conclusion was vital – and the key to accomplishing that was seizing Mount Longdon.

Subscribe Today

The Falklands War had begun on April 2, 1982 when Argentina – which had long claimed sovereignty over the islands it calls “Islas Malvinas” – sent a military expedition which invaded and quickly occupied the Falklands. The British government under Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher hastily assembled an amphibious force of two infantry brigades and dispatched them aboard a heavily reinforced carrier battle group on the long sea voyage to the South Atlantic to recapture the lost British territory. On May 21, the Royal Navy task force disembarked the infantry brigades on East Falkland Island and the fight to defeat the occupying Argentine force began.

After defeating Argentine defenders in the western part of East Falkland – the fighting included a pitched battle to overcome surprisingly stiff Argentine resistance at Goose Green on May 28-29 – the British effort shifted 50 miles eastward to defeat the remaining main Argentine force deployed to defend Stanley. After a long and difficult cross-country forced march over barren terrain in miserable weather, 3 Commando Brigade prepared to launch what British commanders hoped would be the final, war-winning attack on the night of June 11-12.

Although several 3 Commando Brigade units launched attacks that night, 3 Para’s attack to seize Mount Longdon was the most important British objective.

67-cdg-map-001HISTORICAL OUTCOME

Lieutenant Colonel Pike, judging that the young Argentine conscripts manning the enemy defenses of Mount Longdon would prove no match for his superbly trained and highly motivated paratroopers, decided that the quickest way to seize the vital objective was to launch a two-company surprise frontal assault under cover of darkness to roll over the enemy defenses (COURSE OF ACTION ONE: FRONTAL ASSAULT). He assigned A Company to attack the Wing Forward objective on Mount Longdon’s northern slope and B Company to assault Fly Half on the mountain’s western slope. Once those objectives were seized, the attack would continue on, capturing the mountaintop, Full Back objective and, eventually, Wireless Ridge.

Pike held C Company in reserve, prepared to reinforce the other two companies if necessary. He placed the weapons support company (mortars, machine guns and MILAN anti-tank missiles) in a base of fire position along Free Kick stream to the west of Mount Longdon. The paratroopers’ night operation began at 10:15 p.m. on June 11 with a four-hour march to the companies’ attack position. But, after completing the exhausting approach march in the dark and in miserable weather around 2:00 a.m. on June 12, things began to go wrong for 3 Para.

The vital element of surprise was lost before the attacking companies were able to close with the Argentine defenders when one of B Company’s paratroopers stepped on a land mine. The mine’s explosion alerted the enemy to the attack and the defenders began engaging Pike’s paratroopers with a high volume of fire from small arms, recoilless rifles, mortars and machine guns (including .50-caliber Browning heavy machine guns for which the British had no counterpart). With difficulty, B Company paratroopers advanced over Fly Half objective; but in the dark and confusion they missed numerous pockets of Argentine defenders which continued to pour a heavy volume of fire on the British attackers. A Company’s attack was initially repulsed, causing Pike to lead C Company from its reserve position to take over the assault on Wing Forward objective.

The confused and costly combat, often fought at point blank range, raged unabated until dawn when the last Argentine defenders had been killed, captured or driven off Mount Longdon. The stiff defense mounted by the young Argentine conscripts proved an unpleasant surprise to Pike and his paratroopers — 3 Para’s casualties were 17 killed and 40 wounded, while Argentine defenders lost 31 killed and 170 taken prisoner (120 of them wounded).

All 3 Commando Brigade objectives were taken, but the Battle of Mount Longdon was the costliest in British casualties. However, with Mount Longdon and all of the dominant terrain west of Stanley secured by the British, the remaining Argentine forces faced an untenable situation. On June 14, the Argentine commander at Stanley surrendered, ending the Falklands War in a British victory.

READER SOLUTIONS

ACG judges based their selections for winning Reader Solutions and those receiving honorable mention on submissions that chose COURSE OF ACTION TWO: FLANK ATTACK or those whose explanations demonstrated a solid understanding of the key principles for a light infantry night attack. Unlike the historical course of action, COA Two concentrates all three light infantry companies for the strongest possible attack directed at a single point in the enemy defenses. This plan allows 3 Para to approach the objective from an unexpected direction and to avoid coming under fire from enemy weapons on Wireless Ridge. It also facilitates the unrestricted use of supporting firepower while preventing the enemy from employing all of its firepower.

Although it eventually ended in a hard-fought victory, the historical plan, COURSE OF ACTION ONE: FRONTAL ASSAULT, unnecessarily produced heavy casualties for 3 Para’s attackers. Seriously underestimating the fighting ability of the young Argentine conscripts defending Mount Longdon, Pike overconfidently launched a head-on frontal assault conducted by only two-thirds of his infantry strength at the strongest part of enemy defenses. Moreover, spreading the two companies across a wide area resulted in the attack lacking the concentration necessary to overwhelm enemy defenses at a vulnerable point.

COURSE OF ACTION THREE: DOUBLE ENVELOPMENT diffuses battalion strength even more than COA One by isolating all three companies in three widely spread, non-mutually supporting positions. This plan complicates fire support and increases the risk of friendly fire casualties when the companies converge on the mountaintop in the darkness. Finally, this course of action exposes the right flank enveloping attack company to fire from enemy weapons positioned on Wireless Ridge.

AFTER ACTION REPORT

KEY POINTS FOR A LIGHT INFANTRY NIGHT ATTACK

  • IDENTIFY advance route, obstacles and enemy positions via daylight reconnaissance.
  • EVALUATE enemy strengths and weaknesses; don’t underestimate enemy fighting ability.
  • REHEARSE all phases of the attack with key leaders or, time permitting, entire force.
  • SURPRISE the enemy as to location, timing and strength of the attack.
  • CONCEAL the attacking force from enemy observation as it moves to contact.
  • CONCENTRATE attack force on the enemy’s most vulnerable point.
  • SUBSTITUTE skillful maneuver for light infantry’s lack of heavy firepower.

1 Comment

  1. Contrary to being a flank attack, your proposed COA 2 would have launched the entire battalion against the strongest part of the enemy defences. Most of the Argentinian heavy weapons were along the Northern edge of the ridge, in a series of ‘bowls’, with arcs facing North towards ‘Wing Forward’ ( A Coy’s casualties in the historical battle were due to fire from the main ridge). There was also a minefield covering this approach, and the North Western aspect of the ridgeline itself consists of rocky cliffs which would have been almost impossible to assault up. Due to the crest of the feature at ‘Fly Half’ and the siting of the heavy weapons in the bowls, the COA 2 base of fire would have been of limited use in suppressing the defenders, as in the historical battle (a significant number of 6 platoon B Coys casualties were caused by fire from heavy weapons such as recoilless rifles located in the vicinity of ‘Full Back’).

    IMHO Lt Col Pike choose the correct axis of assault for the B Coy attack onto Mount Longdon, but did not commit enough combat power forward. B Coy’s attack soon became split into two parts (6 and part of 5 platoon, and 4 platoon and the remainder of 5), separated by the cliff face and only capable of limited support to each other. The solution may have been a 2 up attack onto ‘Fly Half’, which could have provided enough manpower to maintain the momentum, with a rifle company either side of the natural barrier.
    Another issue was the decision to go for a silent night attack. While maintaining the element of surprise, 2 PARA’s subsequent successful attack onto Wireless Ridge demonstrated the effectiveness of overwhelming fire support.

    Thanks for the interesting articles to read, felt I had to say my piece on this one though, regards.

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. CDG Command Center | Armchair General | Armchair General Magazine - We Put YOU in Command! - […] March 2015 Falklands War Battle, 1982 PDF Pullout Historical Outcome […]

Leave a Reply to Hone Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>